… and a resolution

In a recent post, I wrote about a favourite novel, The Sixth Heaven, by L P Hartley, and, in particular, to a reference therein to a recording of Bach’s magnificent Concerto for two violins. In the book, set shortly after the First World War, the central character, Eustace, and his friend Stephen, listen to a gramophone record of the Bach Double.  I wondered (as I have since first reading the novel many years ago) whether a recording of the concerto had in fact been made prior to 1919, or whether Hartley was using licence in having his characters play that piece on the gramophone.


Thanks to the estimable JDB over at the Augenblick blog, I now have the answer. There indeed was a recording of the Bach Double available at the time, and it can be heard on the US Library of Congress National Jukebox.

The record was made on 1 April 1915 (and it’s no joke). All three movements are available, but here is just the celebrated slow movement.


[Added 1 July: The above line appears to be broken, perhaps only temporarily. There is an alternative link given in the comments below.]

The performers are Fritz Kreisler and Efrem Zimbalist. It is an exquisite performance.  The style will seem old-fashioned to modern ears, but I love the use of portamenti (and the way that it is used to provide a rich variety in the phasing) and its unashamed emotional directness is overwhelming.

It is possible that more than one version of the work was available on record back in 1919, but I no longer feel the need to speculate. Kreisler and Zimbalist were, I feel certain, the performers that Eustace and Stephen listened to in that room in Oxford, on the High, a hundred years ago.

Tagged with: , , , , , , ,
Posted in Classical music
5 comments on “… and a resolution
  1. […] to the estimable JDB over at the Augenblick blog (see comments below), I now have the answer to the question of whether or not a recording of the Bach Double Concerto existed in […]

  2. T E Stazyk says:

    Congratulations on the discovery! Unfortunately there seems to be something wrong with the link and I can’t get it to work.

    • G.H.Bone says:

      Thanks for your message. I think that the links are ok. There seems to be a problem with the National Jukebox. Even when I tried to click through on the Library of Congress website, I got an error message. I’m sure that it will get fixed. In the meantime, the performance is also available here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uFF0_VryZ10 though the sound quality is not quite as good as that from the L of C site.

      • T E Stazyk says:

        Thanks! That worked and it’s fantastic. I like the idiosyncracies and the distinct voices of the violins which don’t always seem to come out in modern recordings.

      • G.H.Bone says:

        Yes, absolutely. And it manages to be emotionally charged without becoming overly-sentimental. By the way, the Library of Congress link seems to be working again. The quality on that link – at least on my equipment here – is better.

        Thanks for calling in and commenting. GHB

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: